First off, thank you for being a supporter! Getting to share this kind of stuff with you guys makes creating content so much more fun.

Let’s get one thing straight before we dive in: a truly great burger needs to nail the fundamentals. I want the classic setup. Give me a perfectly cooked patty, melted cheese, crisp lettuce, a fresh slice of tomato, some sharp raw onion, and a solid hit of ketchup. It’s the quintessential American burger profile. But even with those toppings, the beef still has to be the star of the show. If the meat can't hold its own against a garden-fresh crunch, it doesn't belong on a "best of" list.

After putting plenty of spots to the test, these four Ohio legends stand above the rest.

1. Crabill's Hamburger Shoppe (Urbana)

Crabill's has been an Urbana institution since 1927, operating out of a tiny, cash-only brick building. They serve small, slider-style burgers that are incredibly addictive.

This is the one spot on the list where I happily throw my usual lettuce, tomato, onion, and ketchup order right out the window. By default, their iconic little burgers come dressed with relish and brown mustard, and I order them exactly as is. The combination of their perfectly seasoned beef with that specific, sharp mustard and sweet relish is so dialed-in that you just don't mess with it. You don't go to Crabill's to order just one. You grab a sack of them, and they never disappoint.

2. Gilbert Station Bar & Grill (Burkettsville)

If you blink, you might miss Burkettsville entirely, but Gilbert Station makes the trip worth it. This is also one of the burgers i grew up on.

This small-town pub is famous for some wild menu items; most notably their signature Spankburger, which brings serious heat loaded up with ghost pepper cheese. While those specialty burgers are incredible, the true test of a kitchen is how they handle a classic. They use high-quality Certified Angus Beef for their patties. When you order a classic Twin Burger or a half-pound Cheeseburger loaded up with fresh lettuce, tomato, onion, and ketchup, you get the absolute perfect balance. The crunch of the veggies and the tang of the ketchup perfectly complement the incredibly rich, savory flavor of the beef. It's a flawless execution of a traditional tavern burger.

3. Kewpee Hamburgers (Lima)

Founded in 1923, Kewpee is the second-oldest burger chain in the world. (Fun fact: Dave Thomas actually credited Kewpee as the inspiration for Wendy's.)

Stepping into their downtown Lima location feels like walking into an Art Deco time machine. Because they still grind their own beef fresh from locally raised cattle, the flavor profile is miles ahead of modern fast food. Ordering a double cheese here with the classic garden works is a masterclass in diner nostalgia. The fresh produce against that rich, locally sourced beef on a perfectly toasted bun is living history that actually tastes incredible.

4. The Maid-Rite Sandwich Shoppe (Greenville)

Okay, I know what you're thinking: it's technically not a hamburger. But this loose-meat sandwich is an absolute Ohio legend, and it's close enough to a burger that leaving it off this list felt like a crime.

Opened in 1934, the Greenville Maid-Rite is a quirky, beloved institution famous for its "Gum Wall" (where decades of patrons have stuck their chewed gum on the exterior brick). Inside, they serve steaming hot, incredibly flavorful loose ground beef piled high on a soft bun. By default, they come with mustard, pickle, and onion. I always order mine without the pickle, but you really can't go wrong no matter what you get.

Whether you stick to the classic Maid-Rite, upgrade to a Cheese-Rite, or go all out with a Big Jim (which takes a standard Maid-Rite and stacks ham and cheese on it), it's savory, slightly sweet, completely messy, and absolutely worth the drive.

The Ohio Burger Bucket List

I haven't hit every burger joint in the state yet. Based on the legends, here are the four spots currently sitting at the top of my hit list for future reviews:

The Thurman Cafe, Columbus. Source: Experience Columbus / The Thurman Cafe | Columbus, OH 43206 Zip's Cafe, Cincinnati. Source: Zip's Cafe / Zip Burger - Zip's Cafe Swensons Drive-In, Akron. Source: 10TV / Reader's Digest names Galley Boy best Ohio burger | 10tv.com Bearden's, Rocky River. Source: Cleveland Magazine / Classic Cleveland Restaurants: Bearden's

• The Thurman Cafe (Columbus): Famous for their massive, towering burgers. I want to see if the actual patty holds up beneath all the hype of the legendary "Thurmanator."

• Zip's Café (Cincinnati): Operating since 1926, they are famous for the no-frills, old-school "Zip Burger." It sounds like exactly the kind of classic tavern burger I love.

• Swensons Drive-In (Akron/NE Ohio): An absolute Northeast Ohio staple. Their "Galley Boy" features two mysterious special sauces, and I need to see how it compares to the classics.

• Bearden's (Rocky River): A retro 1950s diner outside of Cleveland. They are famous for their smash burgers, but they also have a notorious "Peanutburger" (yes, peanut butter on a burger) that I might have to be brave enough to try.

I want to hear from you guys in the comments: What do you think of my top 4? Are there any hidden gems in Ohio I missed, and what should be my priority from the bucket list?